Minnesota Trout Unlimited
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
    • Chapters
    • About
    • Join TU
    • Contact Us
    • How to Support Us
  • NEWS
    • Blog
    • Events
    • Monthly Enews
    • Trout Unlimited Minnesota
  • HABITAT
  • EDUCATION
    • Education and Outreach
    • Trout in the Classroom
    • Fishing Skills Programs
    • Great Waters Fly Fishing Expo
    • Foster the Outdoors Program
    • T.U.N.E Camp
  • ADVOCACY
    • Agricultural Runoff
    • Data Centers
    • Feedlots
    • Neonics
    • Nitrates
    • Preventing Fish Kills
    • Public Waters
    • Sulfide Mining
  • FISHING
  • DONATE
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
    • Chapters
    • About
    • Join TU
    • Contact Us
    • How to Support Us
  • NEWS
    • Blog
    • Events
    • Monthly Enews
    • Trout Unlimited Minnesota
  • HABITAT
  • EDUCATION
    • Education and Outreach
    • Trout in the Classroom
    • Fishing Skills Programs
    • Great Waters Fly Fishing Expo
    • Foster the Outdoors Program
    • T.U.N.E Camp
  • ADVOCACY
    • Agricultural Runoff
    • Data Centers
    • Feedlots
    • Neonics
    • Nitrates
    • Preventing Fish Kills
    • Public Waters
    • Sulfide Mining
  • FISHING
  • DONATE

No Hatch to Match? The Silent Decline of Aquatic Insects in Minnesota Trout Streams

Kristen Poppleton2025-03-01T20:35:12+00:00

If you’ve spent any time fishing the cold, clear streams of the Driftless Region, you know that matching the hatch is often the key to success. Hundreds of fly patterns exist to mimic the many species of mayflies, caddisflies, and stoneflies that emerge throughout the season. But in recent years, something has been off. According to many anglers, the legendary hatches that once made for unforgettable days on the water have become few and far between. Dry fly fishing, once the pinnacle of trout angling, just doesn’t seem as effective as it used to be.

So, what’s happening to the insects?

Anecdotal Declines Backed by Science

Anglers have long been the first to notice subtle shifts in nature, and the decline in hatches hasn’t gone unnoticed. Many seasoned fly fishers report fewer rising trout and an absence of once-reliable mayfly emergences. While some might chalk it up to bad luck or changing conditions, scientific studies suggest these observations are part of a much larger trend.

Recent research on aquatic insects in the Midwest has documented staggering declines in mayfly populations, with some studies estimating losses between 50% and 80% (Stepanian et al. 2020). Mayflies, in particular, are highly sensitive to environmental disturbances, making them a biological indicator of stream health. Their disappearance raises concerns, not just for fishing, but for entire aquatic ecosystems.

The Role of Neonics in Declining Hatches

While multiple factors contribute to insect decline (habitat loss, climate change, and pollution), one class of pesticides is drawing increasing scrutiny: neonicotinoids, or “neonics.” In fact, our assistant director Kristen Poppleton recently co-presented about the impact of neonics on aquatic habitats with Ellen Voss of the River Alliance of Wisconsin at Trout Unlimited’ s Driftless Area Stream Restoration Symposium in La Crosse, WI. These widely used insecticides are particularly harmful to aquatic life due to their persistence in the environment and ability to dissolve in water, making them easily transported into streams and rivers.

Minnesota Department of Agriculture (MDA) water samples have found neonics in 97% of tested rivers and streams, with levels frequently exceeding thresholds known to harm aquatic insects. Even at low concentrations, neonics can disrupt insect behavior, impair reproduction, and ultimately lead to population crashes.

How Neonics Enter Our Waters

Neonics are used in agriculture, landscaping, and even pet flea treatments, but the largest source of contamination in Minnesota streams comes from seed treatments, where corn and soybean seeds are coated in neonics before planting. While intended to protect crops from pests, studies show that only about 5% of the applied chemical is absorbed by plants while the rest remains in the soil and washes into nearby waterways.

In heavily farmed regions like southeastern Minnesota, where Driftless trout streams weave through agricultural landscapes, this runoff is particularly concerning. Water sampling consistently detects spikes in neonic concentrations following spring planting and rain events, coinciding with the very time of year when aquatic insect hatches should be at their peak.

The Ripple Effect on Trout Fishing

Fewer aquatic insects don’t just mean fewer rising trout, they disrupt the entire food web. Mayflies, caddisflies, and stoneflies are primary food sources for trout, and their decline forces fish to adapt by feeding on alternative prey. Some anglers have noted more mid-day subsurface feeding and increased reliance on small nymph patterns, but the magic of dry fly fishing has undeniably suffered.

Beyond angling, these declines could have serious economic impacts. Trout fishing is a major driver of tourism in the Driftless Region, contributing nearly $1.6 billion annually to local economies. The annual economic impact in southeast Minnesota alone is close to $900 million.  If insect populations continue to dwindle, it could alter the very character of the region’s famed trout fisheries.

What Can Be Done?

The good news? There are solutions. Some states and countries have already moved to restrict neonic use, with positive results. Ontario, for example, drastically reduced neonic-treated seed use through a verification system, and Europe has enacted widespread bans on outdoor applications of these chemicals.

Minnesota can follow suit. Anglers, conservationists, and policymakers can push for better regulation of seed treatments, more extensive water monitoring, and integrated pest management (IPM) approaches that reduce reliance on broad-spectrum insecticides.

At the individual level, anglers can make informed choices about garden and pet care products, support native plant nurseries that avoid neonic contamination, and stay engaged in conservation efforts. Minnesota Trout Unlimited is actively working to address this issue. 

If you care about the future of our trout streams, now is the time to get involved.


Read more about MNTU’s advocacy work and submit your own story or observations of changes along your favorite trout stream.


Related Posts

May 2025 Macro of the Month: Crane Flies

Living on a trout stream in southeastern Minnesota, it doesn’t require too much effort to keep an eye on what’s... read more

Celebrate Earth Day with your ❤️🗣️👐!

... read more

Macro of the Month: Dark Hendrickson

April 2025 Every spring, as snowmelt charges the streams and the days grow longer, trout anglers eagerly await one of the... read more

Actions you can take TODAY to Honor Earth Month

April 8, 2025 Keeping up with all of the important opportunities to advocate for protection of coldwater fisheries is nearly impossible... read more

MNTU Trout Brook stream improvement project wins engineering award

On February 21, 2025 MNTU’s design engineers on its Trout Brook project, Emmons & Olivier Resources, Inc (EOR), received a... read more

Bill Introduction Season is Here

March 11, 2025 Bills are being introduced at the Minnesota legislature at a rapid pace now and we are following a... read more

The Tiny Winter Black Stonefly: A Cold-Weather Clue to Water Quality: February Macro of the Month

https://www.youtube.com/watch?si=e2h6Bqc4S0LIyQhC&embeds_referring_euri=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bing.com%2F&embeds_referring_origin=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bing.com&source_ve_path=Mjg2NjQsMTY0NTA2&v=JfhFGzSBFxk&feature=youtu.be For many anglers, winter means tying flies, maintaining gear, and daydreaming about warmer days on the water. But, those that... read more

PRESS RELEASE: Environmental groups file lawsuit to ensure momentum to address nitrate pollution continues

DATE: 01/28/25   CONTACT: Sarah Horner, MCEA, [email protected], 612-868-3024 Saint Paul, Minn – Environmental groups filed a lawsuit Tuesday to fortify Minnesota’s... read more

Macro of the Month January 2025: Scuds

Scuds are freshwater shrimp (bottom right) – a crustacean that lives among benthic invertebrates in the stream. read more

Winter Habitat Preferences of Trout in the Driftless Area

By Dr. Jennifer Biederman The Driftless Area, spanning parts of Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Illinois, is renowned for its spring-fed streams,... read more

Contact Us

Contact Page

Send all correspondence to:

Minnesota Trout Unlimited

P.O. Box 845

Chanhassen, MN 55317

Make a Donation to MNTU

Facebook Posts

This message is only visible to admins.
Problem displaying Facebook posts. Backup cache in use.
PPCA Error: Due to Facebook API changes it is no longer possible to display a feed from a Facebook Page you are not an admin of. The Facebook feed below is not using a valid Access Token for this Facebook page and so has stopped updating.
© Copyright 2021 Minnesota Trout Unlimited. All Rights Reserved.